How I Bought My First Bar With $50,000 and a House Fire
Every bar owner has an origin story. Mine starts with a limousine, a fire, and a walk around my neighborhood at midnight while my wife and newborn were asleep.
But what good would this story be if I didn’t give a 20 year lead up to it.
SMALL BAR, DIVISION STREET, CHICAGO
When I was 23-ish I didn’t really have much of a friend group. I had a long term girlfriend, a full time job, and my best friend Paul. At the time, Paul and I were inseparable. I am pretty sure we saw each other every day for multiple years. During this time period, Paul was a bartender at a place called Small Bar on Division Street. This place was pretty magical, the crew was super close, the place was always packed, and it genuinely felt welcoming. Their concept was more like upscale dive with high end cocktails and food. Paul was my anchor and introduced me to a core 10-15 people from the bar, but that probably grew to like 30-40 people that I have met and considered good “bar” friends. Once I was in the crowd, I started to get invited to places, got to participate in the gossip, and would run into people all over the city. The bar industry in Chicago seems so big, but so small at the same time. But more importantly, I belonged somewhere.
For a 23-ish year old outside of high school that feeling is significant. And I think that’s where it all started — the idea that a bar isn’t just a place to drink. It’s a place to belong. This is a time to tell you, I didn’t have my first beer until I was 21 years old. So, drinking and being drunk with people was still very new for me. And to be drunk with people, laughing and doing dumb things — was quite intoxicating.
At this point in my life, I was a truck driver, living with my girlfriend and hanging with my best friend. My life was pretty small, but if you knew me back then (and now), I always had dreams of building something big. As a mere 23 year old, I was a truck driver, painter at a body shop, professional airbrush artist, and even a limousine company owner.
THE LIMO COMPANY NOBODY ASKED ABOUT
Before the bar there was the limousine. When I was a confident, young 21-ish year old I built a party bus from scratch and started a limo company on ~$6,000 — and a few thousand borrowed from my mom’s boss who later became a mentor. It was mildly successful. I probably didn’t give it enough time to fully grow or mature but it did well for only existing for one or two years. I could have done more with it but somewhere along the road I had this massive revelation: I loved building the bus and starting the company, but I dreaded every second of operating it. The day to day wasn’t for me. I had to answer so many calls, deal with people always looking for a discount, had to deal with cleaning it, driving it, selling it, everything. It was too much to bear. I sold it after two years, made maybe $10–15K in profit, and told myself I’d put it toward the next venture someday.
Instead me and my girlfriend got an apartment slightly too expensive for us and ate through it quickly.
The money was gone but the lesson stayed. I knew what I was capable of. I just needed to find the right path that I could go all in on.
THE HOUSE FIRE THAT CHANGED EVERYTHING
Fast forward to about 2022. I’m now engaged, expecting our first child, working in the manufacturing industry and just totally focused on getting our house ready for the baby. The house we lived in was another one of my projects. I purchased it for $157K on my own and slowly renovated every inch of it. When my, now, wife moved in she really lit a fire under my ass to finish the house. But then, on the day after finishing the tile in our new laundry room — a very necessary prerequisite for the nursery build — my neighbor’s house catches fire. It required 3 fire trucks and spread to the two adjacent properties, including mine.
I had spent five or six years renovating that house. We had plans to list it for $600,000 before the fire, at the peak of the housing market in that area. Instead we’re filing an insurance claim and paying $6,000 a month covering two mortgages while they rebuilt it — because they only give you one year of relocation money and it took over two years to rebuild.
We sold the rebuilt house for $550,000. After taxes, fees, and everything we’d burned through during the rebuild, we walked away with roughly $200,000.
Me and my wife sat down and decided to split it three ways. Low risk — S&P 500. Cost mitigation — pay down our mortgage. High risk — buy a bar.
My budget was $50,000 — and I probably had like 50,000 business ideas at that point as well.
PATERNITY LEAVE
During my eight week paternity leave I would keep my sanity by walking up and down my new neighborhood of Berwyn. I’d walk the Depot District. As a bar lover but new dad on a midnight walk, I would just spend my time scoping bars and restaurants. Who’s busy. Who isn’t. What the vibe is. Where I want to go when I get the chance.
But on a whim I googled “bars for sale near Berwyn.”
I found a small gaming cafe listed on a broker-type site. Sale price roughly $90,000. With lawyer fees and inventory, closer to $100,000 all in. This was clearly over my budget and would need my wife’s approval to use some of that other cash we had from the house. But naturally, as any good wife would do, she promptly said no.
So I called my two best friends Tim and Ray. Pitched the idea, showed them the rough numbers based on what the previous owners shared with me, and convinced them to say yes. This is definitely another topic to deep dive into, but understanding revenue and estimating net profits for an existing business is a tough nut to crack.
WHAT WE BOUGHT
We bought a 900 square foot gaming cafe that had been sitting on that block for five years doing almost nothing. Grey walls, black ceiling, and dark ugly granite countertop that didn’t make sense. Grey linoleum floor. Carpet in the back room. Six slot machines and a coffee machine. People came in, had one beer while they gambled, and left.
That was the entire business model.
But here’s what we saw that mattered: those six machines were generating roughly $60,000 a year in net profit. Completely hands off. No cost of goods, no labor, no inventory. Just a check every week. That number covered the majority of our overhead, which meant we could operate the bar side at low cost while we figured out what we were building.
We structured it so I’m the legal owner — easier for liquor licensing — with a partnership agreement reviewed by lawyers that outlines who owns what, what the profit sharing looks like, what the triggers are, etc. I have the majority and my partners have minority stakes. Four-ish years in and they’re still my best friends. Not as much drama as everyone warned me of.
THE THREE YEAR TURNAROUND
I will go over this much more in a different article, but here is the quick synopsis of our first three years:
Year one: down $25,000. We were replacing gambling revenue with bar revenue, and those are not equivalent. To make $100 on the bar side you have to buy the beer, receive the delivery, check it into inventory, store it in the basement, bring it upstairs, pour it, sell about 50 beers, clean tables, clean the chairs, and take out the trash. To make $100 on the gaming side you cash a check. The trade-off is real.
But we kept moving. First thing we did was rip out that carpet — it was genuinely disgusting. We redecorated with a 90s theme. We added menu boards, new lighting, dart boards. We introduced Málört because it’s what we drank — even though everyone told us nobody would order it. Málört is now our best seller and I’m not embarrassed about that at all.
We joined community events — miniature golf, Oktoberfest, anything that put us on the block. We kept the employees who knew the regulars. We focused on building identity.
Year two: flat. Zero. Paid back all the shareholder loans — mostly mine — and finished with no debt and no profit. That felt like a massive win.
Year three: plus $20,000.
We went from negative $25,000 to positive $20,000 in three years. We went from a gray gaming cafe to a profitable community bar doing $200,000–$300,000 in annual revenue. Our regulars are die hard. Working class, mostly minorities, fiercely protective of their spot. We have dart leagues. We have karaoke. We had Málört on tap (the machine broke — sad day) and people who’ve been coming every week for three years. Some even come every single day.
There’s a version of this story where I say it was all part of a plan. It wasn’t. It was a house fire, a midnight walk, a Google search, and two best friends who said yes.
But that’s how bars get built.
WHAT CAME NEXT
That three year turnaround gave me confidence I didn’t know I needed. Not just that I could run a bar, but that I could run one without experience, without a hospitality background, without knowing a single distributor’s name when I started.
That confidence is what led me to my second acquisition — The Beer and Now in Lisle. But again, that’s a different article.
