The Bar Industry Doesn’t Develop People. I Hope to Change That.

I’ve been working at Mars Wrigley for 14 years. In that time I’ve had formal development conversations every six months, feedback loops every quarter, access to classes, committees, cross-functional projects, and mentors. The company didn’t just give me a job — it gave me a career. It invested in who I was becoming, not just what I could do today.

Then I bought a bar. And I entered an industry that does almost none of that.

THE INDUSTRY PROBLEM

The hospitality and food and beverage industry has a development problem. Not because the people in it don’t care — many of them do — but because the economics make it nearly impossible to invest in people the way larger industries can.

Think about it this way. An architecture firm running $40 million in active projects with 20% net margins can afford to hire junior engineers at $60,000 a year and spend 18 months developing them into senior engineers. The margin supports the investment.

A bar running $5,000 a week doesn’t have that luxury. You’re working off percentages. Every dollar matters right now. You can’t afford to carry someone through a development curve when you need somebody pulling that shift tonight.

So what happens? You hire for continuity, not growth. When a manager quits, you go into triage mode. You cover shifts, post the job, interview a few people, and hire whoever can do the job today. Nobody in your existing staff got developed into that role. Nobody was ready. So you go find someone from the outside who’s already experienced — but probably underdeveloped themselves, because the whole industry has the same problem.

You hire from a pool you helped create. And then you wonder why it’s hard to find good people.

WHAT WENT WRONG AT THE BEER AND NOW

I hired a bar manager at The Beer and Now based primarily on his beer knowledge. For a craft beer taproom that seemed like the right call. He knew the product deeply. He could talk about any style, any brewery, any release. From a technical standpoint he was excellent.

What he didn’t have was business acumen, self-awareness, or approachability.

Here’s the thing about approachability in a bar — it’s not a soft skill. It’s a revenue driver. When the person behind the bar makes customers feel unwelcome, or uncomfortable, or like they’re bothering someone, those customers don’t come back. They don’t leave bad reviews necessarily. They just quietly stop coming. And you don’t always notice immediately because the regulars are still there. But over time the new faces stop appearing. The word of mouth dries up. And sales drift down in a way that’s hard to pinpoint.

He never understood the connection between his approachability and our sales numbers. I don’t think he realized there was a problem at all. He was working hard — he genuinely was — but hard work in the wrong direction doesn’t help. He didn’t know how to measure success. He didn’t have the self-awareness to see how he was landing with people. And when there were tasks he didn’t like — cleaning, mostly — he found ways to make other people do them instead.

What I needed was a crucial conversation early on. A real one. Not a hint, not a gentle suggestion — a direct conversation that connected the dots between his behavior and the business outcomes. I didn’t have that conversation as clearly as I should have, and by the time the pattern was undeniable it was already late.

The lesson: hire for people skills first. You can teach someone about beer. You cannot teach someone to genuinely care about other people. A beer expert who’s not a people person will never become a people person. But a people person who knows nothing about beer will figure out beer.

WHAT DEVELOPMENT COULD LOOK LIKE IN A BAR

If I had the time and the resources, here’s what I’d build.

Start with the metrics. Before anything else, make sure every person on your staff understands how the business is measured. What does a good week look like? What does a bad week look like? What’s the breakeven number and why does it matter? Most bar employees have no idea. They show up, pour drinks, go home. They have no context for why being 10% slower on a Tuesday matters or why a $28 average tab versus a $35 average tab is the difference between making payroll and not.

If you give someone that context, you fundamentally change how they show up. Now when they upsell a pint instead of a can, they understand why that matters. When they make a new customer feel welcome instead of ignored, they understand what that’s worth.

Pair that with something they actually want to learn. Ask them. What do you want to get better at? What do you want your next role to look like? If someone wants to eventually open their own bar — and a lot of bartenders do — help them learn the parts of the business they don’t see from behind the bar. Show them how to read a P&L. Let them sit in on an ordering conversation. Explain how the lease works.

That investment costs you almost nothing in real dollars. It costs you time and intentionality. And what it builds is loyalty, capability, and a person who shows up differently because they feel like they’re going somewhere.

WHAT I ACTUALLY WANT TO BUILD

I said earlier that I was going to live with this problem — accept that small bars can’t develop people and just hire for continuity like everyone else does.

I changed my mind.

Here’s what I actually want. I want to build managers who become future small business owners. I want to develop people to the point where they’re ready for their next role — whatever that is — and feel like working at one of my bars gave them something they can carry forward in their career.

I want to standardize our processes well enough that when someone grows out of their role and moves on, I can backfill without the business skipping a beat. And then I want to develop the next person.

I don’t want to see someone bartending for 20 years without growing. That’s not good for them and it’s not good for the bar. People who are growing are engaged. People who are engaged take care of customers. People who take care of customers drive sales.

The bar industry has a development problem. I’m not going to fix it at scale. But I can fix it at my two bars. And that’s worth doing.

Similar Posts

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *